Previous Council Item

Next Council Item Corresponding Agenda
List of Council Meetings List of Reports to Council Sunnyvale Home Page

 

RTC#03-048

February 11, 2003

SUBJECT:

Fremont High School Swim Pool Construction and Budget Modification No. 29 (RTC 03-048)

REPORT IN BRIEF

As Council is aware, the cost figures for construction of the Fremont High School 50-meter swimming pool and swim building were estimated figures, based on the prevailing construction market and known conditions at that time. Council was advised that the eventual completion price could be greater than those estimated figures. Construction costs have, in fact, risen and are more than the amount originally budgeted for by the City. This report outlines the current cost estimates and recommends approval of Budget Modification No. 29 for an additional $210,000, which will enable the City to meet contractual obligations to the Fremont Union High School District.

BACKGROUND

  • April 20, 1999, Fremont Union High School District contacted the City regarding possible joint development of a 50-meter swimming pool, indicating that a ballpark contribution of one million dollars in capital expenditures and an unknown annual operating cost would be the City’s financial contribution toward the project.

  • June 15, 1999, Council directed staff to proceed with a pool partnership feasibility study.

  • May 2, 2000, Council endorsed the concept of a joint use agreement between the City of Sunnyvale and the Fremont Union High School District for a 50-meter swimming pool, and requested the City Manager to include this item in his recommendations at the June budget workshop. The current estimate of the construction cost had risen to $1,400,000 for the City’s share.

  • June 20, 2000, Council authorized the City Manager to enter into a joint use agreement with the Fremont Union High School District to construct and operate the 50-meter swimming pool and adopted a budget for FY 2000/2001 that included those costs.

  • July 18, 2000, an agreement was entered into by both the City and District, for the joint development/use of a 50-meter swimming pool. Estimated construction cost now stands at $1,600,00 for the City’s share.

  • June 26, 2002, "Grand Opening" and public ceremony held.

  • July 8, 2002, Fremont High School 50-Meter Pool open to the public.

EXISTING POLICY

A number of goals, policies, and action statements from the Recreation Sub-Element apply in some fashion to the subject matter of this report. This report is most directly supported by the following Sub–Element statements.

Goal C. develop and enhance the operation of the community recreation fund, maintaining sound financial strategies and practices that will enable the city to provide an array of recreation programs, facilities, and services to a maximum number of citizens while minimizing the impact upon the general fund.

Policy C.3. Utilize available pricing and promotional tools in order to maximize participation and/or use related to programs, facilities, and services, without jeopardizing the integrity and infrastructure of related facilities.

Action Statement C.3.a. Utilize market-based pricing in the establishment of fees, and continually evaluate the effectiveness of pricing strategies.

Action Statement C.3.c. Offer and implement multi-use discount programs where feasible and appropriate.

Policy D.1. Provide a balanced range of program choices to meet the diverse needs of the community.

DISCUSSION

From the conceptual beginning of this project, it has been clear that the estimated total construction cost was a moving target, one that fluctuated as the architectural plans developed and the contract bidding environment changed. The total cost figure has risen from the original estimate of $1,000,000, to $1,400,000, then to $1,600,000 and now to the current estimate of $1,797,104.42.

As indicated in a Report To Council on May 2, 2000, staff was unsuccessful in efforts to negotiate an agreement that would place a cap on the City’s financial exposure or allow it to terminate the agreement unilaterally, should costs exceed a certain amount.

Council is aware that this increased cost will require either additional contributions from the General Fund, or reductions in existing services to offset costs (Community Recreation Fund cannot absorb it).

As authorized by Council, the July 18, 2000, Joint Use Agreement for the Fremont Pool and swim building obligates the City to pay 49% of all construction related costs. Budget Modification No. 29 would provide funding for the City’s share of the most recent construction costs and the estimated additional costs. This also provides for a small reserve should costs escalate further.

FISCAL IMPACT

The construction cost is distinctly different from the on-going maintenance costs and is strictly related to actual construction of the pool, pool deck, fencing, filter room, swim building and related equipment. As indicated in a previous Report to Council (RTC 00-095 May 2, 2000), staff was unable to negotiate a fixed cost or a maximum total cost with the District. Staff also stated that, if approved, the project cost could and likely would increase.

In the FY 2000/2001 Budget, $1,600,000 was identified for the Fremont Swim Pool Construction Project.

To date, the District has billed the City for $1,728,038.42 for construction costs. The City has only paid the $1,600,000 currently budgeted, leaving $128,038.42 as an unpaid balance.

The District has also revised the estimated project cost which will further increase the City’s share by $69,066 or a total overall project cost to the City of $1,797,104.42.

While the total additional amount to complete this project is currently estimated to be $197,104.42, a number of construction items have not been completed and the final costs could be even higher. By contractual agreement, the City is still obligated to pay 49% of any additional construction costs.

Staff is proposing a budget modification of $210,000 be added to the Fremont Swim Pool Project No. 821640, increasing it to a total allocation of $1,810,000. This amount will cover the increased costs (known and estimated) and provide a small reserve. At the completion of the project, any remaining funds from the reserve will be returned to the General Fund.

As an additional comment of interest, for the first six months the pool has been open, the operational costs are within the estimated and budgeted figures.

BUDGET MODIFICATION NO. 29
FISCAL YEAR 2002/2003

Current*

 

Increase
(Decrease)

 

Revised

Capital Projects Fund - General Fund Assets

Expenditures:

         

Project #: 821640
Fremont High School Swim Pool

$334,865

$210,000

$554,865

           

General Fund

         

Reserves:

         

Non-Recurring Events

$1,358,892

 

($210,000)

 

$1,148,892

           
* The original budget for this project was $1,600,000, budgeted in FY 2000/2001. The current year's budgeted amount of $334,865 represents remaining budgeted funds carried over to the current fiscal year.

PUBLIC CONTACT

Public contact was made through posting of the Council agenda on the City’s official notice bulletin board, posting of the agenda and report on the City’s web page, and the availability of the report in the City Clerk’s office, Parks and Recreation Administration office, Community Center, Senior Center, Library and at the Sunnyvale Swim Center at Fremont High School Pool.

A copy of this report was also given to Ms. Holly Lofgren, Chairperson of Friends of the Fremont Pool.

ALTERNATIVES

The contractual obligation of the City calls for payment to the District for 49% of all costs related to construction of the Fremont High School Swim Pool, with no maximum or limit.

  1. Council approves Budget Modification No. 29, adding $210,000 to Project No. 821640 Fremont High School Swim Pool.
  1. Other action as determined by Council.

RECOMMENDATION

Staff recommends alternative 1, Council approves Budget Modification No. 29, adding $210,000 to Project No. 821640 Fremont High School Swim Pool.

Prepared by:
John Lawrence
Leisure Services Manager

Reviewed by:
Robert Walker
Director, Parks and Recreation

Mary Bradley
Director, Finance

Approved by:
Robert S. LaSala
City Manager

Previous Council Item

Next Council Item Corresponding Agenda
List of Council Meetings List of Reports to Council Sunnyvale Home Page